Mindful Spot

Buddhism, philosophy, art.

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Subscribe
  • Donate

Socrates on Moderation as a Harmony that Permeates All Aspects of the Human Soul

March 28, 2021 by Gavril 6 Comments

The Republic of Plato Translated by Allan Bloom“The safest general characterization of the European philosophical tradition is that it consists of a series of footnotes to Plato,” wrote renowned British philosopher Alfred North Whitehead. “I do not mean the systematic scheme of thought which scholars have doubtfully extracted from his writings. I allude to the wealth of general ideas scattered through them.”

To this day, The Republic of Plato (paperback | audiobook) remains a bottomless well of knowledge and wisdom that we can tap into to live a more meaningful life and cultivate the best qualities of our character.

This timeless piece of writing poses everlasting and relevant questions that endure to this day: what is the nature of justice? What kind of community nurtures the finest life for human beings? What is the substance and fate of the soul? How is knowing different from believing?

In the particular excerpt I chose for today, however, I would like to draw your attention to another fundamental question of our life: what is moderation? What is its nature, and how does it manifest in the human soul? Below is an excerpt from one of the best audio productions of Plato’s Republic that dives into the heart of the matter. Performed here by William Sigalis as Socrates and Ray Childs as Glaucon.

SOCRATES ON MODERATION
from The Republic of Plato

Do you think we can find justice without bothering with moderation?

I don’t know how we can do that. And I would hate to bring justice to light and lose sight of moderation. So, please, do me a favor and consider moderation first.

How can I refuse such a request?

Then let’s continue.

At first glance, moderation is more like harmony and proper arrangement than the first two qualities that we have considered.

How so?

As I think of it, moderation is a kind of order and control of various pleasures and desires. It seems to be implied when we say that someone has “self-control,” “is master over oneself,” and similar phrases.

That’s right.

But there is something funny about the expression “self-control.” The one doing the controlling is also the one who is controlled. The master is also mastered.

That does sound strange.

But I think these expressions refer to two different aspects of the human soul. One better, and the other worse. When the better one controls the worse, then we say the person has self-control. This is intended as a form of praise. If the worse aspect, which is far larger than the good one, dominates a person because of poor nurture or bad company, then we censure that person for being immoderate and lacking self-control.

I think that’s a good explanation.

Now, let’s look at the Republic we have created, and you will find an example of such conditions. If the Republic is properly called master of itself, then moderation and self-control are terms that express the rule of the better aspect over the worse.

As I look at it, I find that what you say is true.

Pleasures, desires, and pains are plentiful and diverse in a Republic. Especially in children, women, slaves, and in the majority of so-called free citizens.

That’s easy to see.

But the simple and moderate desires that obey reason and are guided by mind and sound opinion are confined to only a few people. The ones who are best by nature and through education.

That’s true, Socrates.

Glaucon, do you find both of these aspects in your Republic with the common desires of the majority controlled by the wisdom of the few?

I do.

Then, if any Republic can be called a master of pleasures and desires and self-controlled, this one deserves that designation.

Agreed.

And can we call it moderate for the same reason?

Yes.

Also, if there is any Republic, which the rulers and the people who are ruled agree about who should rule, it will be this one.

There’s no doubt about that.

With the citizens in such agreement, where will we find moderation? In the rulers or in those who are ruled?

I suppose we’ll find it in both.

Then, do you see how close we were to the mark when we guessed that moderation is a kind of harmony.

Why do you say that?

Because moderation is unlike courage and wisdom, which are to be found only in one part of the Republic, making it either brave or wise. Moderation extends to the whole running through all the notes of the scale, producing a harmony of all elements: the weaker, the stronger, and the intermediate. And that is true whether you are talking about strength in wisdom, power, numbers, wealth, or any other domain. Therefore, we rightly describe moderation as harmony and agreement about the rule of what is naturally superior over what is inferior, both in republics and in individuals.

I fully agree with you.

Donate & Support

Since I started this website 4 years ago my only aim was and still remains helping all of my readers to discover the path to inner calm through spiritual growth and cultivation of wisdom. I spend all of my free time and resources working on this project and your support plays a vital role in helping me to improve and make this website an invaluable resource for you. If my little virtual home uplifted your spirit or made your day a little bit better, please consider donating to support its further growth.

Your Support Donation

$
Select Payment Method
Your Name and Email

Donation Total: $7.00

Subscribe

Mindful Spot has a free weekly newsletter where I share my findings across Buddhism, philosophy, literature, art, and other sources that allow us to expand our inner world and feel greater connection to each other. Subscribe below:
Subscribe
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Email Share on Pocket
Filed Under: Philosophy

Related Posts

  1. Socrates on Wisdom as a Kind of Knowledge and Good Judgment in Leading People – Mindful Spot says:
    August 20, 2021 at 3:41 pm

    […] wisdom, with another incredibly gratifying audio performance by William Sigalis as Socrates on moderation as a harmony that permeates all aspects of the human soul and then revisit the famous allegory of the cave that questions the nature of perceived reality […]

    Reply
  2. Seneca and Epicurus on the Key to a Happy and Fulfilling Life Available to Everyone – Mindful Spot says:
    July 25, 2021 at 3:48 pm

    […] these witty and life-changing passages from Seneca’s Letters on Ethics with Socrates on moderation as a harmony that permeates all aspects of the human soul, Aristotle on virtues as habits, and then revisit Seneca on the middle way of restraining […]

    Reply
  3. Plato’s Famous Allegory of the Cave and What It Can Teach Us About the Nature of Reality Itself – Mindful Spot says:
    July 12, 2021 at 3:34 pm

    […] of Plato with another immensely gratifying audio performance by William Sigalis as Socrates on the nature of moderation as a harmony that permeates all aspects of the human soul and then revisit Aristotle on virtues as […]

    Reply
  4. To Mingle the Ideal with the Ordinary in Due Proportion: Seneca on Moderation and the Middle Way of Restraining Ourselves – Mindful Spot says:
    June 13, 2021 at 9:48 pm

    […] is something funny about the expression ‘self-control,'” exclaimed Socrates in a conversation with Glaucon while contemplating the virtue of moderation. “The one doing the controlling is also the one who is controlled. The master is also […]

    Reply
  5. Why It’s Important to Cultivate Inner Values: the Dalai Lama on Ethics of Restraint, Virtue, and Altruism – Mindful Spot says:
    May 25, 2021 at 12:18 pm

    […] spiritual leaders of our time, with Aristotle on virtues as habits, and then revisit Socrates on moderation as a harmony that permeates all aspects of the human […]

    Reply
  6. Aristotle on Virtues as Habits: the Small Things that Make the Difference – Mindful Spot says:
    May 9, 2021 at 6:20 pm

    […] this particular portion of Nicomachean Ethics with Socrates on moderation as a harmony that permeates all aspects of the human soul and Roman emperor Marcus Aurelius quotes […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Donate & Support

Since I started this website 4 years ago my only aim was and still remains helping all of my readers to discover the path to inner calm through spiritual growth and cultivation of wisdom. I spend all of my free time and resources working on this project and your support plays a vital role in helping me to improve and make this website an invaluable resource for you. If my little virtual home uplifted your spirit or made your day a little bit better, please consider donating to support its further growth.

Your Support Donation

$
Select Payment Method
Your Name and Email

Donation Total: $7.00

Subscribe

Mindful Spot has a free weekly newsletter where I share my findings across Buddhism, philosophy, literature, art, and other sources that allow us to expand our inner world and feel greater connection to each other. Subscribe below:

Subscribe

Recent Posts

  • Beautiful Day: a Picture Book of Haiku-Inspired Poems Celebrating the Four Seasons
  • The Butterfly Lovers: The Chinese Legend of Liang Shanbo and Zhu Yingtai, Animated
  • The Hermit-Monk Ryokan on the First Days of Spring and How to Maximize Our Aliveness
  • Zen Flesh, Zen Bones: A Collection of Zen and Pre-Zen Writings
  • Your Life Is Your Message: Eknath Easwaran on Finding Harmony with Yourself, Others, and the Earth

Search

  • Facebook
  • Pinterest

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy Copyright 2017-2022 Mindful Spot
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I may earn commissions from qualifying purchases. In more simple terms, this means that whenever you buy a book or a product on Amazon from a link on here, I receive a small percentage of its price.